Magic Estimation is a fast, collaborative technique for relative sizing of many Product Backlog Items (PBIs) at once. The team silently places items into story-point “buckets” (e.g., 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13, 20 …), iteratively reorders them, and holds brief, focused discussions only where disagreement persists. Also known as Silent Grouping or Affinity Estimation, it is most effective when teams need to size a large backlog quickly.
When to Use
- Large backlogs where Planning Poker would be too slow.
- Initial sizing when a team is newly formed or after a major backlog reshuffle.
- Calibration before release or roadmap forecasting, using story points as relative indicators.
Method
- Prepare items & buckets: Print PBIs and set up visible buckets (Fibonacci or similar).
- Silent placement: Team members place items in buckets based on effort, complexity, risk, or uncertainty. No discussion.
- Silent re-ordering: Team members move items they disagree with. Still no discussion.
- Identify hotspots: The facilitator notes frequently moved items (high uncertainty).
- Short, time-boxed discussions: Only for contentious items (90–120 seconds).
- Anchor review: Verify anchor stories in each bucket to stabilize estimates.
- Document outcomes: Capture estimates in backlog tools and mark low-confidence items for later refinement.
Variants & Remote Adaptations
- Two-pass without numbers: First sort items from small→large, then overlay point buckets.
- Bucket sizing hybrid: Use pre-labeled lanes directly.
- Remote setup: Virtual boards (e.g., Jira, Miro) with strict facilitation rules and timeboxes.
Strengths
- Speed: Enables sizing of dozens or hundreds of items in under an hour.
- Whole-team alignment: Silent moves expose misunderstandings before debates begin.
- Focus on relativity: Keeps attention on comparative complexity instead of hours or days.
Common Pitfalls
- Premature discussion: Breaks flow. Solution: enforce silence in early rounds.
- False precision: Story points are relative, not absolute time measures.
- Anchor drift: Recalibrate anchors regularly when technology or processes change.
- Overuse: For a small backlog or highly complex items, Planning Poker often yields deeper insights.
Advanced Practices
- Confidence tagging: Mark estimates with confidence levels to guide refinement.
- Outcome pairing: Combine estimation with outcome hypotheses to avoid feature factory bias.
- Flow-based forecasting: Use Magic Estimation alongside throughput and cycle-time data for probabilistic delivery forecasts.
CALADE Perspective
CALADE uses Magic Estimation to quickly establish relative sizing at scale. We integrate it with anchor stories, flow metrics, and evidence-based forecasting. Our coaches apply the method pragmatically: estimates support informed decisions, without turning into rigid control mechanisms.
Related Terms
· Planning Poker
· Bucket Sizing
· Affinity Estimation
· Story Points
· Backlog Refinement
← back to list